This site uses affiliate links - we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full disclosure ->
Book Review | Historical Fiction

The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett

The Calamity Club review: a good story and an awesome audiobook that could have been told in 400 pages or less.

3.25 / 5 stars
The Calamity Club review book cover by Kathryn Stockett
Started on audiobook through Libby, finished in hardcover from Barnes & Noble

At a Glance

Title The Calamity Club
Author Kathryn Stockett
Genre Historical Fiction
Setting Mississippi during the Great Depression, from the Delta to Oxford
Publisher Spiegel & Grau
Format Read Audiobook on Libby, then hardcover from Barnes & Noble
Audiobook Narrators Jenna Lamia and January LaVoy
My Rating
Verdict Read it if you loved The Help and have plenty of time, and go with the audiobook if you can.

The Calamity Club Review: A Long-Awaited Follow-Up to The Help

After a break of more than 17 years, Kathryn Stockett is back with a doorstopper of a follow-up to her first novel, The Help. I know this will be controversial, because The Calamity Club made the rounds on all the blogs and talk shows as THE book to read this summer, but I seriously thought it was just okay.

The story itself is good, the audiobook is awesome, and I liked the wacky characters. She really could have told this story in 400 pages or less, though. It just went on and on unnecessarily.

What Worked for Me

After the negative feedback on The Help, Stockett focuses this time on mostly white characters in Mississippi during the Great Depression. Birdie’s younger sister, Frances, has married up and left the Delta for the big city of Oxford. The family hasn’t heard from Frances in months, and like many of the farmers around them, they’re going to lose their farm if they don’t get help, and fast. So Birdie is sent by train to visit her little sister in her fancy new life and ask for a loan. Little does she know that Frances’s whole life is a bit of a lie, and they’re struggling financially too.

In a parallel narrative, we follow Meg, a young girl living in an orphanage, and her fight to survive and be reunited with her mom. As you’d expect, the paths of these two families cross, and we learn about all sorts of corruption and misuse of power in the old South.

Stockett brings the same humor to serious topics that she did in her first book. This time it’s the Great Depression, with heavy subjects like misogyny, institutional corruption, and the hypocrisy some people live with. I love Birdie’s character, and I did enjoy several of the others. The message of found family and resiliency is the heart of the book, and for that, I’m glad I read it.

The audiobook deserves its own mention. I listened to the first half, and it was 100 percent better than reading the book.

Where It Fell Short

The length is the big one. This book did not need to be this long, and the story would have been stronger tightened up to 400 pages or less.

The story itself is good, the audiobook is awesome, and I liked the wacky characters. She really could have told this story in 400 pages or less, though.

Birdie, as I expected, becomes the hero who tries to save everyone. Although I love her, I think many of the other characters are just overblown stereotypes.

And when my Libby checkout ran out halfway through, I switched to the hardcover because I had to know what happened.

Who Should Read It

I think it’s a great book for anyone who enjoyed The Help. If you like Southern historical fiction with humor, big personalities, and a found-family message, there’s a lot here for you.

If you’re short on time or patience with long books, you might skip this one.

And if the corrupt orphanage and the 1928 eugenics and sterilization laws storyline is what draws you in, I’d also recommend Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate, which explores those topics and is well written.

Final Thoughts

Should you read The Calamity Club? I’d say yes, but only on audiobook, and only if you have a lot of time to spare. My rating is 3.25 out of 5 stars.

Should You Read The Calamity Club?

You enjoyed The Help
You can listen to it on audiobook
You like Southern historical fiction with humor and found family

Get New Posts Delivered to Your Inbox

Weekly book reviews, RV life guides, campground picks, and exclusive gear finds sent straight to your inbox.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy